Groups do have a natural talent, which is the evaluation of ideas, rather than their creation. The conclusion of the psychological literature, therefore, is that people should be encouraged to generate ideas on their own and meetings should be used to evaluate these ideas.
from Brainstorming Reloaded
I think most managers would know this. It takes science (ready pyschology) to tell us so, but expereince would have brought you to similar results.
Click here to read my suggestions for brain storming>